Are Conversation Hearts Gone Forever? Exploring Their Uncertain Fate

Valentine’s Day is synonymous with love, chocolates, and, of course, conversation hearts. These sugary morsels adorned with sweet messages have long been a staple of romantic gestures and festive celebrations. However, questions linger in the air: Did conversation hearts go out of business? In this article, we will explore the history of conversation hearts, their rise to fame, the challenges faced by the manufacturers, and the current status of these iconic candies. Get cozy as we unravel the sweet mystery behind this beloved treat!

The Sweet History of Conversation Hearts

Before diving into their current status, it’s essential to understand the history of conversation hearts. These candies have a rich legacy that dates back to the early 19th century and have evolved significantly over the years.

The Origins of Conversation Hearts

The story begins in 1847 with a Boston-based company named Necco, short for the New England Confectionery Company. This company first produced the “Sweethearts” candy, which consisted of small, heart-shaped candies with sentimental messages printed on them. The pioneering idea of combining sugary treats with affectionate phrases gained immense popularity.

Growth and Popularity

As decades passed, conversation hearts became more than just a seasonal candy. By the late 20th century, they became an intrinsic part of Valentine’s Day celebrations. People of all ages would purchase these messages of love to express their feelings to sweethearts, friends, and family.

Their charm lies in their simplicity: a small, crunchy candy that delivers a colorful and delightful message. The conversation hearts became available in various colors and flavors, and their iconic phrases such as “Be Mine,” “Love You,” and “Kiss Me” captured the hearts of many.

The Changing Landscape of the Candy Industry

While conversation hearts were thriving, the candy industry began shifting dramatically due to various factors. Understanding these changes is crucial in uncovering whether conversation hearts truly went out of business.

Competition from Other Confectionery Products

As the candy market expanded, new competitors emerged. Modern consumers shifted their preferences toward:

  • Artisan chocolates
  • Gourmet candy options

These alternatives often provided a more luxurious or unique experience compared to traditional candies like conversation hearts. The added appeal of rich flavors and creative packaging attracted younger consumers, leaving classic options like conversation hearts fighting to maintain relevance.

Changing Preferences and Trends

The explosion of social media and altered romantic expressions also played a significant role. Younger generations show preferences for more personalized gifts, memories, and experiences. Customizable items like engraved jewelry have overshadowed novelty gifts, making conversation hearts wane in popularity.

The Great Necco Crisis of 2018

The fortunes of conversation hearts took a dramatic turn with the 2018 closure of Necco. The once-thriving company declared bankruptcy, and it led to significant speculation about the future of the beloved candy.

Details of the Closure

Necco’s closure was attributed to a multitude of factors, including:

  • Rising operational costs
  • Inability to adapt to changing consumer demands

As a result, the production line for conversation hearts came to an abrupt halt, leaving many fans heartbroken during the 2019 Valentine’s Day season.

The Resurgence of Conversation Hearts

Despite the dire situation, hope remained on the horizon. In 2019, Spangler Candy Company acquired the rights to produce conversation hearts, initiating a revival.

The Return of the Iconic Candy

When Spangler Candy reintroduced conversation hearts in 2020, fans of the candy congregation breathed a collective sigh of relief. The newly produced hearts retained the iconic messages that everyone cherished, assuring consumers that their favorite Valentine treat was not lost to history.

Manufacturing Challenges

Despite the return, challenges remained for Spangler Candy. The company faced:

  • High demand
  • Supply chain difficulties

These obstacles raised concerns about how well the company could keep up with the demand, especially leading into notable holidays like Valentine’s Day.

Conversation Hearts in Modern Times

The return of conversation hearts sparked excitement among fans, but their enduring relevance in a modern candy market is still a point of discussion.

Market Trends and Consumer Sentiments

Surveys conducted after the return of conversation hearts revealed a mixed sentiment. While many nostalgic consumers celebrated their comeback, younger generations remained indifferent due to the shiny allure of contemporary options. The question lingered: Is there still a place for conversation hearts in today’s confectionery world?

Marketing Strategies for Renewal

To ensure the longstanding love for conversation hearts persists, it’s crucial for Spangler to implement effective marketing strategies. This could include:

  • Social Media Campaigns: Engaging younger audiences through vibrant imagery, TikTok challenges, and heartwarming user-generated content to reignite interest.
  • Collaborations with Influencers: Partnering with social media personalities for themed campaigns could further elevate the candy’s profile.

Conclusion: Are Conversation Hearts Out of Business?

Concluding this sweet journey through the history and current state of conversation hearts, it becomes clear that these legendary candies are not out of business. While the challenges they faced were substantial due to industry transformations and company struggles, their return offers a sense of nostalgia and hope.

Though the future remains uncertain as evolving trends affect consumer preferences, conversation hearts continue to hold a special place in the hearts (pun intended!) of many. With effective marketing and genuine engagement with modern consumers, conversation hearts could enjoy prolonged sweetness, proving that they are still relevant in an ever-changing world.

As Valentine’s Day approaches, these tiny hearts of love are set to return to stores, waiting to spread messages of affection once more. Here’s to hoping that conversation hearts can recapture the magic that made them a beloved treat for generations. Whether as a token of love or a playful sharing of sweet nothings, they might still have a long and loving role in the tradition of Valentine celebrations.

What are conversation hearts?

Conversation hearts are small, heart-shaped candies that are typically associated with Valentine’s Day. Each piece is usually embossed with a short message or phrase, such as “Be Mine,” “Kiss Me,” or “Love You.” These candies are loved for their sweet, chalky texture and playful messages, making them a staple treat during the Valentine’s season.


Originally known as “Necco hearts,” these candies have been produced since the 19th century. They hold a nostalgic charm for many who remember buying or exchanging them as children. While most people enjoy their sweetness, conversation hearts have also been a source of debate, given their unique texture and flavors. They are seen as a symbol of the holiday, emblematic of innocent affection and playful romance.

Why did conversation hearts disappear?

The disappearance of conversation hearts can be traced back to the closure of the Necco candy factory, where they were traditionally made. The factory shut its doors in 2018, leading to a significant gap in production. The abrupt stop meant that many fans of these candies were left without their beloved Valentine’s treat during the following holiday season.


The manufacturer of conversation hearts faced challenges in reviving production due to licensing and operational issues. As a result, significant uncertainty loomed over their availability. This left consumers wondering if conversation hearts were just a nostalgic relic of the past or if they would make a comeback in the future.

Are conversation hearts expected to return?

There is hope for the return of conversation hearts, especially following the acquisition of the Necco brand and its recipes by the Spangler Candy Company. In recent updates, Spangler has indicated that they have been working diligently on reviving the classic heart candies. The goal is to produce them in time for the next Valentine’s Day celebration, which has renewed excitement among fans.


However, there are still logistical challenges that the new management must navigate. They need to ensure the quality and integrity of the candy match that which consumers remember. If everything goes as planned, consumers might once again be able to enjoy conversation hearts, although some changes in flavor or design could occur in the initial production run.

What will happen to the messages on the hearts?

The messages printed on conversation hearts are iconic and form a significant aspect of their appeal. While there is a plan to retain many of the traditional messages, Spangler Candy Company has also hinted at introducing new phrases to modernize the candy’s appeal. This has sparked some debate among nostalgic fans who wonder if new messages will dilute the vintage charm that conversation hearts are known for.


As the brand seeks to balance nostalgia with innovation, it will be interesting to see how the new designs resonate with consumers. While some may be enthusiastic about contemporary phrases reflecting today’s culture, others may prefer the timeless classic messages. Ultimately, the decision on which messages to continue using will likely hinge on consumer feedback and market trends.

Will conversation hearts taste the same?

One concern among fans of conversation hearts is whether the flavor profile will remain unchanged. The Spangler Candy Company has expressed an intention to maintain the original taste that many people have come to love over generations. However, with the transition of ownership and potential modifications in production methods, there may be slight variations in flavor that could occur.


Consumers will need to taste the new conversation hearts to compare them with their beloved predecessors. Given the loyalty of fans, the company is likely to prioritize flavor integrity to ensure a successful return. As we await their comeback, it will be interesting to see if they can recreate the signature flavor that defines conversation hearts.

Are there any alternative candies for Valentine’s Day?

If conversation hearts do not return in time for Valentine’s Day, several alternative candies are available. Many brands offer heart-shaped chocolates, gummy candies, and foil-wrapped treats that can serve a similar purpose in celebrating the occasion. Chocolate hearts, in particular, are a popular choice for expressing affection and appreciation.


Additionally, other novelty candies can also evoke the spirit of Valentine’s Day. Candies like lollipops with sweet messages, personalized wrappers, and even homemade confectionery can offer a heartfelt alternative to conversation hearts. While they may lack the same historical significance, they can still make meaningful gifts during the season of love.

How can I keep updated on conversation hearts’ status?

To stay updated on the status of conversation hearts, consider following Spangler Candy Company on social media platforms or subscribing to their newsletter. Companies often share important updates regarding product releases, flavor changes, and other exciting news with their followers. Social media is also a great way to connect with fellow fans who can spread the word about any developments.


Furthermore, online candy retailers and local confectionery shops may provide updates on their stock and availability. Websites and blogs dedicated to candy news can also be great resources for keeping track of the latest information regarding conversation hearts and other seasonal treats. Being proactive about following these channels will ensure you don’t miss any announcements about their possible return.

Leave a Comment