5 Delicious Pizza Sauce Substitutes You Can Try Today!

Looking to elevate your homemade pizza game but find yourself without traditional pizza sauce? Fret not, as we bring you 5 delectable and easy-to-find alternatives to traditional pizza sauce that will tantalize your taste buds and impress your family and friends. Whether you’re in a pinch or simply looking to experiment with new flavors, these tasty substitutes will add a refreshing twist to your pizza creations.

From creamy pesto to zesty barbecue sauce, these inventive pizza sauce alternatives are sure to satisfy your craving for a flavorful and satisfying pizza experience. Say goodbye to plain old tomato sauce and dive into a world of diverse and tantalizing flavors that will take your homemade pizzas to new heights. Let’s explore these 5 scrumptious pizza sauce substitutes that you can start experimenting with today!

Quick Summary
If you don’t have pizza sauce, you can use a simple alternative by mixing tomato paste with a bit of olive oil, garlic, and Italian seasoning. This makeshift pizza sauce can add some flavor and moisture to your pizza. Alternatively, you can also use marinara sauce, canned diced tomatoes, or even barbecue sauce as a creative substitute.

Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto

One delightful alternative to traditional pizza sauce is sun-dried tomato pesto. This flavorful, tangy spread is made from sun-dried tomatoes, basil, garlic, pine nuts, and Parmesan cheese, creating a rich and aromatic base for your pizza. The sun-dried tomatoes add a robust, intense sweetness to the pesto, while the basil and garlic provide a refreshing and savory balance. The pine nuts contribute a nutty, creamy texture, and the Parmesan cheese adds a salty, umami depth to the sauce.

When using sun-dried tomato pesto as a pizza sauce substitute, spread a thin, even layer across the pizza dough to impart a bold burst of Mediterranean flavors. Its versatility also allows for customization, as you can adjust the consistency by adding olive oil or water to achieve your desired thickness. Whether you prefer a thin and crisp crust or a chewy, thick base, sun-dried tomato pesto provides a delightful departure from traditional pizza sauce that will elevate your homemade pizza to new culinary heights.

Alfredo Sauce

Alfredo sauce, with its creamy texture and rich flavor, makes for an indulgent alternative to traditional pizza sauce. This velvety sauce is typically made with butter, heavy cream, and Parmesan cheese, adding a luxurious twist to your pizza. The combination of buttery, garlicky, and cheesy flavors can elevate the taste of your pizza, giving it a gourmet touch.

Using Alfredo sauce as a pizza base offers a delicious departure from the classic tomato-based options. The creamy consistency pairs well with a variety of toppings, from grilled chicken and spinach to bacon and mushrooms. Whether you opt for a homemade Alfredo sauce or a store-bought version, its decadent taste is sure to add a deliciously distinctive spin to your pizza creations.

Barbecue Sauce

Barbecue sauce is a flavorful and tangy alternative to traditional pizza sauce. Its smoky, sweet, and slightly spicy flavor profile can add a unique twist to your pizza. When used as a sauce base, barbecue sauce infuses your pizza with a rich and indulgent taste that pairs well with a variety of toppings. Whether you’re making a classic barbecue chicken pizza or experimenting with new flavor combinations, barbecue sauce can elevate your pizza to a whole new level.

The versatility of barbecue sauce allows for endless customization, making it suitable for both meat and vegetarian pizza options. Its caramelized sugars and savory undertones complement ingredients like grilled chicken, bacon, red onions, and even pineapple, offering an irresistible medley of flavors. Additionally, the deep, smoky notes of barbecue sauce can provide a delicious contrast to the creamy texture of melted cheese, creating a mouthwatering experience for your taste buds. Next time you’re craving pizza with a twist, consider using barbecue sauce as a delectable substitute for traditional pizza sauce.

Garlic Butter

Garlic butter is a luxurious and flavorful alternative for pizza sauce that adds a rich and savory twist to your favorite pizza. To make garlic butter pizza sauce, simply mix softened butter with minced garlic, a touch of salt, and chopped fresh parsley or basil for added freshness. Spread this delectable mixture over your pizza dough for an indulgent and aromatic base that pairs well with a variety of toppings.

The garlic butter sauce will melt and infuse the pizza with its aromatic flavor as it bakes, creating a deliciously buttery and garlicky essence that is sure to tantalize your taste buds. This sauce is particularly popular with those who enjoy a more subtle and mellow base for their pizzas, as the buttery richness complements the toppings without overpowering them. Next time you’re craving a unique and decadent pizza experience, consider trying garlic butter as a flavorful sauce alternative that brings a touch of indulgence to every bite.

Olive Oil And Fresh Herbs

Olive oil and fresh herbs offer a simple yet delicious alternative to traditional pizza sauce. To prepare this flavorful substitute, start by brushing a thin layer of high-quality extra virgin olive oil over the pizza crust. Next, sprinkle a generous amount of freshly chopped herbs such as basil, oregano, thyme, or rosemary over the olive oil. The combination of the aromatic herbs and the rich, fruity flavor of the olive oil creates a refreshing and light base for your pizza.

The olive oil and fresh herbs add depth and complexity to the pizza, infusing it with a fragrant, herbaceous essence that perfectly complements the melted cheese and toppings. This substitute is a great option for those who prefer a lighter, herb-infused flavor profile or are looking for a healthier alternative to traditional pizza sauce. Additionally, it’s a versatile choice that pairs well with a variety of toppings, making it a delightful option for customizing your pizza to suit your taste preferences.


Hummus is not only a great dip for pita bread and veggies, but it can also make a surprisingly delicious pizza sauce substitute. Its creamy texture and rich, savory flavor can add a unique twist to your pizza. Simply spread a layer of hummus on your pizza dough before adding your favorite toppings. The subtle blend of chickpeas, tahini, and olive oil in hummus can bring a lovely creaminess and nuttiness to your pizza, making for a delightful Mediterranean-inspired dish.

Additionally, hummus is a versatile ingredient that can be customized with various flavors such as roasted red pepper, garlic, or spinach, offering a wide range of options to complement your pizza ingredients. Whether you prefer a classic margherita pizza or a more adventurous combination of toppings, hummus can provide a tasty and healthy alternative to traditional pizza sauce. Its smooth consistency and bold flavors make it a fantastic choice for those looking to experiment with unconventional pizza sauces.


Salsa can be a flavorful and zesty alternative to traditional pizza sauce. Its combination of tomatoes, onions, peppers, and herbs adds a fresh and tangy kick to your pizza. The chunky texture of salsa can provide a delightful contrast to the gooey cheese and chewy crust, creating an exciting flavor profile.

Moreover, using salsa on your pizza opens up a world of different variations, as there are countless types of salsa available, from mild to spicy, and with various added ingredients such as mango, pineapple, or black beans. This allows you to customize your pizza to your desired level of heat and flavor. Salsa also adds a pop of color to your pizza, making it visually appealing and appetizing. Whether you opt for traditional tomato-based salsa or decide to experiment with fruit-infused varieties, using salsa as a pizza sauce substitute can be a fun and delicious way to shake up your pizza routine.

White Sauce

White sauce, also known as b├ęchamel sauce, is a creamy and indulgent alternative to traditional tomato-based pizza sauce. Made with butter, flour, and milk, this sauce provides a rich and velvety base for your pizza toppings. To make a white sauce pizza, simply spread a generous layer of the sauce over your pizza dough and top it with your favorite ingredients such as cheese, vegetables, and meats. The result is a luscious and savory pizza that offers a delightful departure from the classic marinara flavor.

Additionally, white sauce can be customized with herbs and spices to elevate the taste profile of your pizza. For a touch of elegance, consider incorporating garlic, thyme, or nutmeg into the sauce to add depth and complexity to your pizza creation. Whether you’re looking to switch up your pizza routine or cater to a crowd with diverse tastes, white sauce offers a versatile and delectable option to satisfy your pizza cravings.

Final Words

Incorporating different pizza sauce substitutes can elevate the flavors and textures of your favorite pizza recipes, providing new and unique culinary experiences. Whether you opt for the tangy twist of barbecue sauce or the robust, rich flavor of pesto, experimenting with diverse sauces can add an extra layer of excitement to your dining routine. By exploring these alternatives, you have the opportunity to expand your palate and introduce a fresh dimension to traditional pizza toppings. Embracing these enticing substitutes can inspire creativity in the kitchen and enhance your enjoyment of this beloved comfort food. So go ahead and infuse your pizza with a touch of innovation, and embark on a journey of culinary exploration that will delight your taste buds and bring a new twist to pizza night.

Leave a Comment